Rewriting the Response Path: Silent Tampering and Provider-Signed Defense in BYOK LLM Agents

LLM agents convert model outputs into consequential actions, including communications, code changes, and financial transactions. Developers often trust evidence such as test results and execution logs. We identify a response path integrity gap in Bring Your Own Key configurations used by roughly 88 percent of mainstream agents. Because traffic passes through a user-authorized relay, the relay can modify plaintext LLM responses after alignment but before execution without breaking encryption. A minimal attack rewrites one execution bearing field and regenerates the remaining response using the user key while preserving the model style. Experiments reveal false green verification, where malicious code modifications pass public tests while silently defeating security checks. On APPS, 99.7 percent of publicly passing solutions retained downgraded behavior without developer-visible warnings. Tests on SWE bench, AgentDojo, and ASB across five frontier models show that single-field rewriting can redirect agents while preserving apparent task completion. We propose sign-c, a server-side scheme that authenticates execution bearing fields and outgoing queries. A local shim verifies them before action, while encryption protects confidentiality. The defense rejected all tampered responses with zero false rejections and only 0.0167 percent latency overhead.