APEX4: Efficient Pure W4A4 LLM Inference via Intra-SM Compute Rebalancing

W4A4 quantization promises full utilization of INT4 Tensor Cores, yet group dequantization overhead on CUDA Cores has driven existing systems to mixed-precision fallbacks. We present the first systematic study of how intra-SM compute balance governs this bottleneck. Through controlled benchmarks across four GPUs from Ampere and Ada architectures, we identify the Tensor Cores to CUDA Cores throughput ratio (ρ) as the primary hardware indicator: the W4A4-g128 kernel yields 2.0--2.5\times speedup on RTX 3090 (ρ=16) yet degrades to 0.43--0.47\times on A100 (ρ=64) in compute-bond scenarios, establishing W4A4 viability as platform-dependent rather than universally infeasible. Guided by this finding, we build APEX4, which co-designs pure INT4 GEMM kernels with ρ-aware granularity adaptation to mitigate the CUDA Cores dequantization bottleneck. APEX4 achieves perplexity within 0.63 of FP16 on LLaMA-2-70B and outperforms W4Ax Atom-g128 by 4.0%--4.4% in zero-shot accuracy. Deployed as a drop-in replacement in unmodified vLLM, it delivers up to 1.66\times end-to-end speedup on L40S (ρ=8), and 1.78\times on RTX 3090 (ρ=16), 2.09\times on A40 (ρ=16), while recovering A100 (ρ=64) to 1.20--1.40\times via the mixed-granularity mode.