Cross-Dataset Generalization in Urdu Fake News Detection: An Empirical Study with XLM-RoBERTa and a Length Confound Analysis

Urdu fake news detection remains under-resourced despite Urdu being spoken by over 231 million people worldwide. While prior work has demonstrated strong in-domain performance on individual Urdu datasets, cross-dataset generalisation has received little systematic attention. This paper presents the first cross-dataset generalisation study for Urdu fake news detection, using two publicly available balanced datasets: the Ax-to-Grind Urdu corpus (10,083 articles, 15 domains) and the Notri-Fact Urdu dataset (13,388 articles). We fine-tune xlm-roberta-base under four experimental conditions, in-domain on each dataset and two zero-shot cross-domain transfer directions, comparing against TF-IDF baselines using Logistic Regression and Support Vector Machines. Our experiments reveal a striking asymmetry: Notri-Fact to Ax-to-Grind transfer achieves a macro F1 of 0.771, while the reverse collapses to F1 of 0.005, with the model predicting fake for 99.7% of test articles. We demonstrate that this collapse stems from a systematic length confound in Ax-to-Grind, where fake articles average 117 words versus 35 for real articles, a 3.4x asymmetry inducing shortcut learning. A length ablation capping articles at 50 words yields only a 0.0067 F1 drop, confirming the confound inflates but does not solely drive in-domain performance. We provide a reusable diagnostic methodology that combines bidirectional transfer analysis and prediction-collapse inspection to identify confound-driven behavior in multilingual fake news detection settings.