Contextual Semantic Relevance Tracks fMRI BOLD Responses During Naturalistic Speech Comprehension

Naturalistic language comprehension requires listeners to process both local probabilistic expectations and contextual semantic relations. Surprisal has been widely used to quantify local word unexpectedness, but evidence that it robustly predicts fMRI BOLD responses during continuous comprehension has been mixed. This study investigates whether contextual semantic relevance, defined as how strongly an incoming word relates to its recent semantic context, predicts BOLD responses during naturalistic speech comprehension. We analyzed two public fMRI datasets, the Alice dataset and the Moth dataset, treating them as complementary rather than identical replications. Transformed BOLD responses were modeled with generalized additive mixed models (GAMMs) and original continuous BOLD time series were tested with FIR/deconvolution analyses. In Alice, semantic relevance was significant across all 12 ROIs (region of interest), whereas surprisal was not significant after FDR correction. In Moth, semantic relevance showed consistent negative effects across all 30 ROIs, while surprisal showed no comparable pattern. These findings suggest that semantic relevance is a promising BOLD-sensitive metric of contextual semantic fit. More broadly, our findings support the view that slow hemodynamic responses during naturalistic speech comprehension may be especially sensitive to contextual semantic integration, whereas local probabilistic prediction error may be more difficult to detect reliably with fMRI. In this sense, semantic relevance extends computational models of language comprehension from prediction alone toward context-sensitive semantic integration.